The document I have from CJR does say 1855, but the Carbonear Methodist burial records list no Thomas Pike buried in February 1855. They do, however, list the burial of a Thomas Pike, aged 100, on 25 February 1835.
25 Sept 2004 update: now that I've personally seen the headstone, I'm certain that 1835 is the correct year. I took pictures, which you can see for yourself here.
NAME PLOT STONE DATE AGE OTHER PARTICULARS ==== ==== ===== ==== === ================= Pike, Ann 7 H Jan. 14 1856 16 yrs Daug. of Edward & Mary Pike of Mosquito. Pike, Artie 16 J Jan. 23 1891 3y 10m Child of J & Susannah Pike Pike, Bessie 32 D Jan. 16 1929 66 yrs Daugher of Stephen B. Pike Pike, Catherine 7 W Dec. 20 1805 81 yrs Pike, Charles 7 V ____ 4 1813 4 yrs Son of Frances & Jane Pike Pike, Clarise May 37 F Oct. 3 1909 14 yrs Child of Colin & Sarah Ann Pike, Edgar 14 R July 28 1871 29y 3m Pike, Edward 7 G Nov. 18 17__ 30 yrs Pike, Edward S. 21 B Dec. 14 1895 73y 9m Pike, Edward T. 14 S April 6 1883 8_ yrs Pike, Elizabeth Jane 39 L Dec. 7 1907 55 yrs Wife of Jabez Pike Pike, Elizabeth Martha 13 K Aug. 24 1882 63 yrs Wife of Edmund Pike Pike, Eugene Joseph 21 A Oct. 24 1880 26 yrs Pike, Francis 7 T June 11 1835 75 yrs Pike, Francis 14 P Nov. 30 1873 73 yrs Pike, Harold 16 J Dec. 20 1891 10 mos Child of J & Susannah Pike Pike, Jabez W. 39 L May 5 1904 51 yrs Pike, James Capt. 16 K 1925 Pike, Jane 7 S Feb. 10 1856 72y 5m Wife of Francis Pike Pike, John 6 P July 1 1855 88 yrs Pike, John 24 I Oct. 5 1818 69 yrs Of John Pike, John 12 B July 18 1856 67 yrs Pike, John Thomas 17 N Aug. 22 1825 14y 6m 12d Son of Ed & Ann Pike of Mosquito Pike, Julia 34 G Apr. 14 1898 48 yrs Wife of Capt. Reuben Pike Pike, Julianna 7 G Dec. 5 2y 10m Infant daughter of Ed Pike Pike, Mark 23 H Sep. 15 1903 78 yrs Pike, Mary 21 B April 4 1897 72y 6m Pike, Mary 12 A Dec. 11 18__ _7 yrs Wife of John Pike of Mosquito Pike, Mary 14 O Sep. 10 1886 77 yrs Wife of Francis Pike Pike, Mary Ann 14 S March 3 1882 75 yrs Wife of Edward T. Pike Pike, Mary Ann 23 G Aug. 22 1893 66 yrs Wife of Mark Pike Pike, Rachel Eliza 7 L Dec. 7 1810 4 yrs Daughter of John & Sarah Pike Pike, Capt. Reuben 34 G Dec. 29 1905 60 yrs Lost at sea Pike, Richard 7 B Oct. 28 1836 16y 7m Son of Samuel & Ann Pike of Mosquito Pike, Samuel 1 M Nov. 16 1844 62 yrs Of Clown's Cove Pike, Sarah 1 M Nov. 30 1821 Wife of Samuel Pike Pike, Sarah 7 M April Pike, Simeon Francis 35 D Sept. 7 1908 71 yrs Pike, Stephen B. 32 D Jan. 25 1918 85 yrs Pike, Stevo B. 32 D 1958 88 yrs Born 1870 Pike, Susannah 16 K 1930 Pike, Susannah 22 P Nov. 11 1846 37 yrs Wife of George Pike, daughter of Richard & Mary Hayward Taylor. Pike, Thomas 1 K Feb. 22 1855 100 yrs Pike, Wm Augustus 37 F Dec. 15 1911 26 yrs Child of Colin & Sarah Ann Pike
NAME PLOT STONE DATE AGE OTHER PARTICULARS ==== ==== ===== ==== === ================= Pike, George V. 5 E Nov. 1895 Pike, Julia 2 C2 Mar. 25 1913 54 yrs Wife of Thomas Winsor Pike, Samuel 5 E Nov. 1895 Pike, Sarah Jane 5 C Oct. 1895 64 yrs Wife of Capt. Woodbine Pike Pike, Woodbine 5 C April 4 1902 78 yrs Husband of Sarah Jane Pike